Access to homeowner insurance in California has become increasingly difficult over the past year. Seven of the 12 largest insurance companies in the state, including Allstate, State Farm, and Farmers, have either stopped or limited issuing new policies, particularly in areas with high wildfire risk. This trend has affected home sales, as buyers are unable to obtain necessary insurance for mortgages. Insurers cite escalating wildfire severity, rising construction costs, and restrictive regulations as major challenges.
Companies Reducing Coverage
Prominent companies like Allstate and State Farm have halted new applications, while Farmers has scaled back its policies. USAA now imposes stricter wildfire safety standards and will not insure previously uninsured homes. Other insurers, such as Travelers, Nationwide, Chubb, AmGUARD, Falls Lake Insurance, and The Hartford, have also restricted or ceased offering policies in high-risk areas.
High Costs for Insurers
California’s nearly 40 million residents, 55 percent of whom are homeowners, require protection against disasters. However, insurers face increased costs due to frequent wildfires and inflation-driven hikes in construction material prices. For instance, California fires in 2022 caused $380 million in damage. Insurers often use reinsurance to manage risks, but reinsurance premiums have also risen sharply, by 50 percent between April and July 2023.
Regulatory Challenges
Proposition 103, passed in 1988, restricts insurers from raising premiums by more than 7 percent without state approval. This regulation, combined with limits on using current wildfire data in rate calculations, hinders insurers’ ability to balance costs. The approval process for rate changes can take over six months, complicating insurers’ ability to adjust to rising risks.
Finding Insurance Alternatives
Homeowners receiving nonrenewal notices should immediately contact their insurance agents. Alternatives include exploring other insurers, as over 100 companies still write policies in California. “Non-admitted” insurers, though less regulated, can provide necessary coverage. The California FAIR Plan offers basic fire protection as a last resort, with recommendations to seek better options periodically.
State Initiatives
The California Department of Insurance (DOI) is working on strategies to attract insurers back to the state. The Sustainable Insurance Strategy aims to:
These efforts are designed to enhance insurance availability and affordability for California homeowners amidst rising environmental risks.
Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.